
That pic above is not the best Key Lime pie in Key West. I will get to that shortly. Last week, on a whim, I took a trip to Key West to try as many Key Lime pies as possible so that I can help YOU have the best Key Lime experience when you visit Key West. This article will also be followed with another on Thursday regarding the best way to visit Key West and what you can do aside from having nine pieces of Key Lime pie in three days.

4. The first I tried was an evening outing. You know, it’s the evening and you just want something sweet? I walked about a half mile to have this piece of pie and it did not disappoint. They make a pretty nice Sangria too. Look at the meringue! It must have been 3 inches high. This was seriously a really good Key Lime pie. Definitely better than what I can find in upstate NY. There’s actually two Moon Dog locations. This one is not my winner…

3. This Key Lime was truly one of the top three on the island. And yes, I had a great breakfast and followed it up with Key Lime pie at 8:30 in the morning. What was as good as the Key Lime pie was the breakfast and the restaurant itself. It has a fantastic laid back atmosphere. I ate in their outside area and loved it. It has a phenomenal relaxed tropical feel.
2. Those two pics are from El Meson de Pepe, a great Cuban restaurant. I had an incredible Cubano sandwich for lunch, which was way better than the one I get at Cheesecake Factory at home. Then of course I had this truly delicious piece of Key Lime pie. You can find this place in the Mallory Square area of Key West.
I went to nine different restaurants for my Key Lime quest to find the best Key Lime, but I won’t make you read about all of them. The next piece of Key Lime is my winner for best Key Lime Pie in Key West!

1. I can hear you through the internet: “But Phil, that doesn’t look like Key Lime pie! It’s chocolate and on a stick!
You’re darn right that it’s on a stick and it’s covered in chocolate. The first three pieces of pie I documented here are all great, but this has the awesomeness of Key Lime pie but with chocolate added and you can eat it on a stick while walking around outdoors. How many things in life are made worse by adding chocolate? Definitely not Key Lime pie when you’re in Key West.
Here’s a Phil idea I came up with on my Key Lime quest. Look back at the title picture at the top. It’s of a piece of Key Lime pie with a little lime slice for decoration. When you get that, take that little decorative lime slice and squeeze it so that it oozes lime juice all over your piece of pie. The tart lime flavor goes through the roof! Enjoy!
Thanks for reading and stop back tomorrow for tips on how to truly maximize you Key West trip!
~Phil






















































